Rafael Mediterranean Restaurant: A Cozy Upper East Side Gem (Review)
Craving an authentic Mediterranean experience without leaving the Upper East Side? Look no further than Rafael, a relatively new restaurant making waves with its fresh ingredients, vibrant flavors, and inviting atmosphere. Located at 973 Lexington Ave, Rafael promises a delightful culinary journey from the sunny shores of the Mediterranean to the heart of New York City. While my rating comes in at a 6.5, let's dig in and see what this place has to offer.
A Warm Welcome: Ambiance and Atmosphere
Stepping into Rafael feels like entering a chic, modern oasis. The decor is tastefully done, creating an atmosphere that’s both cozy and upscale. Imagine soft lighting, comfortable seating, and a general sense of sophisticated ease. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner, a special occasion celebration, or even just a relaxed evening with friends. The attention to detail in the interior design elevates the dining experience beyond just the food, contributing to an overall enjoyable visit.
A Culinary Adventure: Exploring the Menu
Rafael’s menu is a celebration of Mediterranean flavors, showcasing fresh, seasonal ingredients prepared with skill and passion. While there were some highs and lows in my dining experience, several dishes truly stood out and are worth highlighting.
* **The Starters: A Mezze Masterclass**
No Mediterranean meal is complete without a selection of mezze, and Rafael delivers. Their hummus is a must-try, boasting a creamy texture and rich, nutty flavor. Drizzled with olive oil and served with warm, fluffy pita bread, it's the perfect way to begin your culinary journey. The tzatziki is another winner, cool and refreshing with a delightful blend of yogurt, cucumber, and dill. It’s a light and tangy counterpoint to some of the richer dishes on the menu. The Tomato and Pepper Salad offers a vibrant burst of freshness, showcasing the natural sweetness of ripe tomatoes and the subtle heat of peppers. Lastly, their Baba Ghanoush, with its smoky eggplant flavor and creamy texture, is a true delight, showing what this spot can do with some great prep.
* **Bread and More: A Supporting Cast That Shines**
Don't underestimate the importance of good bread! Rafael's sesame rolls are a delightful addition to the meal. Soft, slightly sweet, and sprinkled with sesame seeds, they're perfect for sopping up flavorful sauces or enjoying on their own. They added to the cozy feeling of sharing the various plates with the table, creating a sense of conviviality.
* **Fresh From the Garden: Salads and Grilled Delights**
The Vegetable Salad at Rafael is a showcase of seasonal produce, artfully arranged and bursting with flavor. While I found it a bit underwhelming overall, the freshness of the ingredients was undeniable. However, the Grilled Eggplant absolutely redeemed the salad course! Tender, smoky, and drizzled with a vibrant green herb sauce, it was a standout dish that showcased the kitchen’s skill in highlighting the natural flavors of simple ingredients.
* **A Sweet Ending: Decadent Dessert**
For those with a sweet tooth, Rafael offers a tempting selection of desserts. The Chocolate Dessert is a must-try. Rich, decadent, and served with a creamy sauce and chopped nuts, it's the perfect way to end your Mediterranean feast. The portion size is generous enough to share, making it a sweet and satisfying conclusion to the meal.
Navigating the Experience: Addressing the 6.5 Rating
While the overall atmosphere and the standout dishes certainly impressed, the relatively lower rating of 6.5 reflects inconsistencies in the experience. Some dishes, while showcasing fresh ingredients, lacked the depth of flavor one might expect from a top-tier Mediterranean restaurant. The service, while generally attentive, could occasionally be slow or inattentive. However, it’s important to remember that Rafael is still relatively new, and these are kinks that can be ironed out over time.
The Price of Paradise: Understanding the $$$ Price Range
Rafael falls into the $$$ price range, indicating a higher-end dining experience. While the quality of the ingredients and the ambiance justify the price for some, it’s important to be aware of the cost before making a reservation. Expect to spend a significant amount per person, especially if you indulge in multiple courses and drinks.
Final Verdict: Worth a Visit?
Despite some minor inconsistencies, Rafael Mediterranean Restaurant offers a compelling culinary experience on the Upper East Side. The cozy, modern atmosphere, coupled with several standout dishes, makes it a worthwhile destination for those seeking authentic Mediterranean flavors. While the price point may be a deterrent for some, the overall experience and the potential for further improvement make Rafael a restaurant to watch. If you're in the neighborhood and looking for a taste of the Mediterranean, give Rafael a try. Don't be afraid to order the hummus, tzatziki, and grilled eggplant—you won't be disappointed! With some refinements, Rafael has the potential to become a true gem on the Upper East Side dining scene.
