Robert Beveridge

3/30/2025, 8:00:31 PM

As a Nottingham Forest fan living in NYC, how I’ve only discovered this bar is beyond me. Decent selection of European draft beers and food, ordered the bacon sarnie (kudos on calling it that btw), I also kept seeing pretzels the size of a small car being served which was impressive in its own right, so even if you don’t like sports but like massive knots of dough this is a sight to behold in its own right. Atmosphere wasn’t obnoxious and plays all the important football matches with a scheduled and well organized setup, TV’s are labelled with what game they’re playing and they have a calendar on their website with what games they’re showing in advance. Although they should be more active with their instagram but hey? So congratulations Smithfield Hall, you’ve successfully managed to drag me from the depths of Brooklyn all the way into the city to what football. I look forward to coming here more often.

Ash N. Patel

6/24/2024, 2:57:07 PM

Lived next to this bar for 8 years. Smithfield hall still reigns supreme as the best place to watch soccer/futbol in nyc. Definitely make reservations for big matches and be ready for a packed bar. This is where the Europeans in nyc go to see their teams !

Kate Milinevska

9/8/2023, 11:40:23 AM

It’s a nice huge sports bar! Came here to watch the opening of football season and wasn’t disappointed. Huge selection of draft beers 🍻 Big food many but food is just okay Chicken wings not Buffalo wings Classic burger with cheese was good and French fries is delicious 🤤 For the burger - onions were missing Great service Plenty of space Draft beers was served in not chilled glass I guess because of a lot of clients. But the most upsetting situation- not really a nice neighborhood- so many drug addictive people was outside , just be careful after you leave this place

Brian Giambalvo

1/28/2023, 10:05:30 PM

Perfect game-watching experience either solo or with a massive party. The owner was more than willing to accommodate our request to watch a college basketball game during a Man U game. Food was great and service was even better!

Misc

4/6/2025, 7:11:20 PM

TLDR; There's basically a mandatory $40 fee/person at the door to watch "big games". I have never ever left a bad review for any establishment in my life, no matter how atrocious. But this warrants a review because it is disingenous, bordering on scammy. Came a long way from NJ to this bar to watch the Manchester derby since someone recommended it on the United Stand Channel. There was a mandatory $40 fee at the door "for drinks". I had not planned to drink and would have ordered food instead but of course that was not possible. But since I had traveled such a long distance and the game was already ten minutes in, I paid to go in. When I got in, the place was packed full (which is why I gave a 5 for atmosphere). There was nowhere to sit, much less order the drinks I had paid for outside. I asked a waiter and was told the bar was full. They could have told me this outside and I wouldn't have wasted my money or time going in. But it's easy to see why they didn't say that before I went in, since of course there's a mandatory $40 entry fee. Anyway I left the place almost immediately. Missed the Manchester derby and lost $40. Would not recommend if you have an alternative. I just dug through their previous reviews and saw that people have complained about this in the past. Clearly, they won;t do anything about it. For a club as big as United, we can do better. I will be in touch with bars/pubs in the area to see how we can set up an alternative location for United fans on game days. Stay tuned.

Tiffany Waters

2/23/2025, 6:07:13 PM

I recently took my daughters to NY and when we were leaving heard good things about this place and stopped to get brunch. The guard that was out front ask for our IDs and while we were waiting a couple come up and a man pushed my daughter. The security guard proceed to let them in. I requested to speak to the manager Kevin who came out aggressive and combative when we tried to tell him what happened outside. He was extremely racist and unapologetic. So if your looking for a horrible experience and don’t care about customer service this is the place to go to. I will be reaching out to the owner and hope he can pull the camera to see how nasty his manager is to potential patrons especially women. Pls think twice before going to this establishment. The man in the picture is the guard.

Jack Zakka

7/19/2024, 7:29:30 AM

Great worldwide sports ambiance! Beside, the friendly staff at all times! Highly recommended (games, casual hangout, hosting private parties) I consider Smithfield Hall as my 2nd home!

Lee W

1/9/2025, 5:37:45 PM

As a family of Nottingham Forest fans in NYC we were obliged to attend the Boxing Day game against Spurs. The bar has several teams who use the location of which Forest being the biggest 😉😂 Arrived at 9am for a 10am KO, greeted by the landlord (top guy from Louth) and settled down with a Guinness. Food was really good , we had the Irish and American breakfasts which were quality. All the Premier League games were on with one end of the bar Forest at one end and West Ham the other, both who rolled out winners, it was a great atmosphere.and a great place to watch the football

Nathaniel Meek

3/21/2025, 5:14:47 AM

One of the worst customer service experiences I’ve ever had. Came in to watch the NCAA Tournament with friends. They had just ordered fries but the waitress told me the kitchen was closed. No biggie, but then she said I can go get a slice across the street and bring it in if I want. I did just that and came back and then the doorman said I couldn’t bring food in. I told him what the waitress said and my friends concurred, so he asked the bartender who said I couldn’t. I asked him why the waitress told me otherwise causing me to go across the street in the pouring rain, if now they were gonna make me eat it outside. He then started yelling at me, so I found the waitress and asked what was up. She said they decided to be jerks about it so I said fine, I’d eat outside the bar. Then the bartender yells “go ahead eat your pizza!” So I go to get it and then he starts yelling at me in front of my friends about making a scene. INSANE! So I decide to be the bigger man and go outside to eat it anyway. I kid you not the doorman comes out 5 mins later, I’m thinking he’s gonna apologize or something, he says I’m 86’d!!!! I obviously argued with him, and even used some choice words at that point, cause I was rightfully pissed since I took my slice outside despite the contradictory messages and YELLING. So he doubles down and says I have to leave and am banned! What is with this place??? At least he let me say bye to my friends before leaving, but it was mega embarrassing as they were work friends. Totally wild! This place needs to be shut down or have a full staff overhaul or something! I’ve worked in the service industry and seen some wild stuff but this takes it.

Mostyn Powell

2/27/2025, 5:36:07 PM

Food was excellent, Philly Steak hit the spot. Comfortable seating and atmospheric. Would recommend this as a great watering hole to stop at.

Yossi Shelef

3/6/2025, 12:29:39 AM

It's probably the best ⚽️ bar in New York and definitely one of the best sports bars in the US. Fantastic party atmosphere during World Cups, Euros, Copa America, and whenever one of the home teams plays - it's especially fun for Manchester United, Bayern Munich, and Barcelona games. The setup is great - you can view multiple screens from any spot, which is great for weekend matchdays, Champions League days, March Madness, NFL gameday, or whenever there are multiple games going on simultaneously. There's a large selection of beers on tap, a full bar, and excellent bar food - the burgers, Jameson wings, and fries are imho among the best in the genre. The service is professional and friendly, which adds to a phenomenal atmosphere.

Aida Gomez

10/18/2024, 9:51:09 PM

I just love you, guys!!! My fifth visit after leaving from work to enjoy my draught Blue Moon and fried calamari my "must have choices" when coming your way! Great ambiance, great service, great location! Whenever you are in town, don't miss it! Even if the place is packed and you end being standing, you'll have a great time being "solo" or with friends. Kudos to management; you know your stuff!!! 💕